Loading tutorials…
Loading tutorials…
Every site has dead backlinks pointing at 404'd pages. Reclaiming them is the highest ROI link work in SEO — the links already exist; you just have to redirect or replace the destination.
Who this is forMarketers with a site older than 12 months. The longer your site exists, the more dead backlinks you have. Reclaiming 20-50 broken links is usually achievable in a single afternoon.
What you'll need
Step 1
Ahrefs → Site Explorer → enter your domain → Broken backlinks (left rail under Backlink profile).
Open Site Explorer → enter your apex domain → click Broken backlinks in the left rail.
Ahrefs returns all referring URLs pointing at 4xx pages on your domain. Expect 50-500 results depending on site age.
Sort by DR descending to see the highest-value broken links first.
Filter to 'Live' link status to remove backlinks that have already been removed by the referring site.
Step 2
Group broken backlinks by the target URL on your site. One target URL might have 5-20 broken links pointing at it.
Look at the target column — this is the dead URL on your site that's being linked to.
Sort by target URL. You'll see clusters: 8 backlinks pointing at /old-guide, 5 backlinks pointing at /removed-product, etc.
Each cluster is one decision: where should the dead URL redirect?
Prioritize clusters by total DR sum. A cluster with 5 backlinks averaging DR 50 is worth more than 20 backlinks averaging DR 15.
Step 3
For each dead target URL, decide: (a) 301 to closest existing page, (b) create a new page at the URL, or (c) leave as 404 if no relevant alternative.
Option A — 301 redirect to closest relevant existing page. Best for URLs where you have a clear successor. Example: /old-guide → /new-guide.
Option B — re-create the page at the same URL. Best for URLs where the backlinks suggest demand for that exact topic. Build a fresh page targeting the original intent.
Option C — leave as 404. Use only if there's no relevant successor AND the link sources are low-quality (DR < 20).
Avoid: 301 to homepage. Google's spam-link policy explicitly discounts homepage 301s from dead URLs — they're treated as soft 404s.
Step 4
Implement the redirects in your stack: Cloudflare Workers, Next.js redirects, WordPress Redirection plugin, .htaccess, or platform-specific UI.
Implement 301s in the canonical place for your stack. Cloudflare Workers and Page Rules for edge-level. Next.js next.config.js for app-level. WordPress Redirection plugin. Shopify's URL Redirects panel.
Test each redirect manually in incognito before declaring done. Sometimes 301s get caught by your CMS's own routing and end up as 302s or chains.
Avoid redirect chains. A → B → C is two hops; Google discounts authority on chains > 3 hops. Always 301 directly to the final destination.
Document the redirects in a sheet. Six months from now, knowing why /old-guide redirects to /new-guide saves a future incident.
Step 5
For target URLs with 5+ backlinks pointing at them and no clean 301 successor, rebuild the page at the original URL.
For each high-value broken cluster without a clean 301 candidate, build the page.
Match the original intent. If /ultimate-guide-to-X had 8 backlinks, the rebuilt page should target the same intent at the same URL.
Publish at the original URL (not a new URL). The whole point is to reclaim the link equity already pointing at the old slug.
Submit the rebuilt page to GSC for re-indexing once it ships.
Step 6
For broken backlinks pointing to genuinely irrelevant URLs (acquisitions, sunset products), pitch the publisher to swap the link.
Some broken backlinks point at URLs you genuinely don't want to bring back — sunset products, acquired-and-shut-down services, etc.
For these, the play is outreach: email the publisher, point out the broken link, suggest a relevant replacement URL on your site.
Lead with the publisher's benefit: 'Your readers are hitting a 404 — here's a working URL on the same topic.'
Reply rate is 15-30% on this kind of outreach because you're solving the publisher's problem. Much higher than cold outreach.
Common mistakes
301-ing everything to the homepage
What goes wrong: Google treats homepage 301s from deep dead URLs as soft 404s. The link authority is discounted. The reclamation effort produces zero ranking lift.
How to avoid: 301 only to a topically-relevant successor page. If no relevant page exists, either rebuild the original or leave the 404 in place.
Creating long redirect chains
What goes wrong: A → B → C → D. Google passes authority less efficiently across each hop. Three or more hops and the authority drops significantly. Effectively undoing the reclamation work.
How to avoid: Always redirect directly to the final destination. Audit existing chains using Ahrefs Site Audit's 'Redirect chain' issue, then collapse.
Using 302 instead of 301
What goes wrong: 302s tell Google 'this is temporary, keep indexing the original.' Authority doesn't pass cleanly. You think you reclaimed the link; Google thinks you didn't.
How to avoid: Use 301 for permanent moves. Reserve 302 for genuine A/B tests or true temporary redirects (rare in practice).
Ignoring low-DR broken links
What goes wrong: You only fix DR 50+ broken backlinks and ignore the DR 20-49 ones. In aggregate, the DR 20-49 cluster represents 60-80% of the total reclaimable authority. You're leaving 70% of the work undone.
How to avoid: Fix the high-DR ones first for visibility, then do a sweep of mid-DR ones. Anything below DR 15 can usually be skipped — diminishing returns.
One-off reclamation instead of quarterly
What goes wrong: You run reclamation once, fix 50 broken links, and never check again. Twelve months later, you've accumulated another 80 broken links — same problem, larger surface area.
How to avoid: Calendar reclamation as a quarterly task. Each pass takes 2-3 hours and recovers 10-30 links. The compounding effect over years is significant.
Recap
Done — what's next
How to run an Ahrefs backlink gap analysis (and get usable targets)
Read the next tutorial
Hand it off
Broken-backlink reclamation is the highest-ROI link work in SEO and the most ignored. A vetted technical SEO specialist on EverestX will run quarterly reclamation, set up the redirects, and own the publisher outreach — typically $400-1,000/mo at $14-16/hr.
See specialist rates
Sites under 2 years old: 20-100 broken backlinks. Sites 2-5 years old: 100-500. Sites over 5 years: often 500+. The volume grows with age and content turnover.
A direct 301 from a dead URL to a relevant successor passes approximately 90-95% of the original link authority. Chains, irrelevant targets, and 302s pass significantly less.
Generally no — Google's algorithm has been better at ignoring spammy links since 2020. Reserve disavow for clear penalty situations (manual action notices) or PBN linking patterns you can prove.
Cross-check with Google Search Console → Links → Top linked pages. Look for 4xx pages with external link counts. Ahrefs misses about 5-15% of GSC-known links; running both produces a more complete list.
Yes on most platforms. Cloudflare Bulk Redirects supports CSV upload (up to 10,000 rules). WordPress Redirection plugin supports CSV import. Next.js requires editing next.config.js but can be templated.
Ahrefs
Backlink gap is the most powerful module in Ahrefs and the easiest to misuse. This walks through the qualification logic that separates 'links a specialist would chase' from '5,000 directory submissions.'
Ahrefs
Your Health Score is 68 and the issue list has 4,000 items. This walks through the 10 errors that matter most — the ones causing real ranking damage — and how to fix each.
Ahrefs
Batch Analysis lets you pull DR, UR, traffic, and backlink counts for up to 200 URLs at once. The skill is what you do with the export — most teams stop at 'I have a CSV.'
Ahrefs
You're paying $249-449/mo for Ahrefs. The question isn't whether the tool is worth it — it's whether you're using more than 10% of it. This is the honest decision framework.